0%
5180 Orange Grove Road, Gosport, IN
Beautiful lakefront home on Lake Hollybrook. Remodelled and ready for you to enjoy. Lofty ceilings with rustic wood finishes and wood deck for that lakehouse feel that you and your friends will love. Updated kitchen and bath for a modern feel while maintaining that lakehouse vibe. Cozy fireplace inside and the great outdoors to enjoy. Updated roof with insulation, and new deluxe vinyl plank flooring. All new electric, new plumbing, new gutters, soffit, and fascia, new furnace, doors and windows ... nothing to do but chill :) Outside there are trails, clubhouse for rent, neighborhood activities and more. Below is 750 SF of storage; Smaller than a basement, bigger than a crawl.

Fizbo Market Record — March 31, 2026 Compared against 8 active listings in Gosport, 9,356 across Indiana, and 182,000+ nationwide, here is where this property stands. This lakefront home on Lake Hollybrook a unique blend of rustic charm and modern updates. The listing notes lofty ceilings with rustic wood finishes, an updated kitchen and bath, and a fireplace, all set amidst the tranquil surroundings of the lake. Notably, the property has been extensively renovated, featuring new electric, plumbing, gutters, soffit, fascia, furnace, doors, and windows. Priced at $210,000, this listing ranks in the 25th percentile for price among active listings in Gosport, with 75% of competing properties being more expensive. In a state-wide context, it falls into the 22nd percentile, indicating a relatively modest pricing strategy. The list price is equivalent to 0.95x the city median, suggesting a slight discount relative to comparable homes. One notable aspect of this listing is its size: at 750 sqft, it's one of the smallest properties in Gosport, ranking in the 0th percentile for square footage. However, its lot size of 2178 sqft puts it in the 13th percentile among competing listings, offering a relatively outdoor area. The property's age, built in 1945, also ranks in the 13th percentile, indicating that it's not particularly old or new compared to other homes in the city. In terms of differentiators and gaps, this listing stands out for its lakefront location and extensive renovations. However, with only 0 features listed among competing listings, there may be opportunities to highlight specific upgrades or amenities that set this property apart. Conversely, the absence of a garage – present in 62% of competing listings – could be an area where objections arise. With 8 active listings in Gosport and an average days on market of 86, this listing is competing against a relatively small pool of properties. However, its price/sqft ratio of $280 (75th percentile) suggests that it's priced competitively relative to other homes in the city.
Property Type
Single Family
Style
Ranch
Year Built
1945
Lot Size
2,178 sqft
Price / Sqft
$280
Days on Market
4 days
Full Baths
1
Subdivision
Lake Hollybrook
MLS #
MBR22085485
Listing Type
Residential
Market
MIBOR
Middle
Owen Valley Middle School
High School
Owen Valley Community High School
5180 Orange Grove Road, Gosport, IN 47433 — Owen County
Jeneene West
Jeneene West Realty, LLC

8442 E Hadley Road, Camby

6228 Trotter Road, Indianapolis

8418 Burket Way, Camby

841 Cherry Tree Lane, Greenwood
1005 Main Street, Beech Grove
213 Drewood Drive, Trafalgar
6437 Greenspire Place, Indianapolis
6128 Trillium Woods Court, Indianapolis
5210 Crawfordsville Road, Indianapolis
5613 Willowridge Court, Indianapolis
5412 Margate Road, Indianapolis
4408 Clovelly Court, Indianapolis

6979 McFarren Road, Gosport

7859 Moore Road, Gosport

7863 Moore Road, Gosport

31 E Main Street, Gosport
5155 Orange Grove Road, Gosport
How this home compares across city, state, and national benchmarks
Listed at $210,000, this 2-bed house in Gosport is 100% above the Census median home value of $104,800 for Gosport. Compared to 4 other 2-bed homes in Gosport (averaging $201,000), this property is 4% above average. Indiana's median home value is $139,802, putting this listing 50% above the state benchmark. The U.S. national median home value is $334,900.
Where this listing falls among 6 homes for sale
Gosport has a population of 1,113 with a median household income of $51,250 and a homeownership rate of 54.6%. The median home value is $104,800 and the median rent is $924/mo.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023, Fizbo listing data