0%
0%
4 W Henley Street, Carthage, IN
This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home is full of character and boasts stunning original woodwork throughout. The spacious living room features a built-in bookcase, a cozy window seat, and a decorative fireplace, perfect for hosting a large gathering or just a relaxing evening. Host memorable dinners in the formal dining room, beautifully accented with a built-in cabinet. The updated kitchen and bath provide modern convenience while maintaining the home's classic appeal. One bedroom conveniently located on the main level, with two additional bedrooms and a versatile loft area upstairs-perfect for families, guests, or a home office. Unwind on the enclosed front porch or take advantage of the large, fenced-in yard. This delightful home seamlessly blends classic charm with functional living spaces, making it a wonderful place to call your own.
Fizbo Market Record — March 30, 2026 Compared against 2 active listings in Carthage, 10,229 across Indiana, and 182,059 nationwide, here is where this property stands. This Traditional-style home a rich history with its 1900 build date placing it among the top 1% of oldest listings in the city. The listing notes original woodwork throughout, which adds to its unique character. With 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, this home's specs are slightly below average for the city, where 86% of competing listings have more bathrooms. However, its 3,852 sqft living area is right in line with the median size of homes in Carthage. Priced at $247,000, this listing ranks as a mid-pack offering in the city, priced above 50% of active inventory but below the top quartile. Its price-per-sqft ratio suggests an aggressive pricing strategy, as it's one of the lowest-priced listings per sqft in the city. When compared to the median house price in Carthage ($236,000), this listing is priced at a premium of 1.05x. Statewide, its price puts it in the lower third of all active listings. One notable differentiator for this property is its large lot size (0.31 acres), which provides ample space for outdoor activities and is a rare feature among competing listings (only 12% have lots over 0.25 acres). However, its lack of modern features like an in-law suite or garage may be seen as a drawback by some buyers. With only one other listing with the same bed/bath configuration in Carthage, this property stands out for its unique character and historic charm. Its price is right in line with the median for 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom homes in the city ($247,000), but its specs suggest it may be a more affordable option than competing listings with similar features. This listing competes against only two other active listings in Carthage, making it a relatively rare find in this market. With no days on market data available, we can't assess the speed at which homes are selling in this area. However, its unique features and price point suggest that it may appeal to buyers looking for a more affordable option with character and charm.
Property Type
Single Family
Style
Traditional
Year Built
1900
Lot Size
13,503 sqft
Price / Sqft
$64
Days on Market
78 days
Full Baths
1
Subdivision
No Subdivision
MLS #
MBR22075179
Listing Type
Residential
Market
MIBOR
Elementary
Knightstown Elementary School
High School
Knightstown High School
4 W Henley Street, Carthage, IN 46115 — Rush County
Lindsay King
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
307 Henley Avenue, Carthage
308 N Market Street, Carthage
10074 N 400 W, Carthage
How this home compares across city, state, and national benchmarks
Listed at $247,000, this 3-bed house in Carthage is 178% above the Census median home value of $88,900 for Carthage. Compared to 2 other 3-bed homes in Carthage (averaging $137,000), this property is 80% above average. Indiana's median home value is $139,802, putting this listing 77% above the state benchmark. The U.S. national median home value is $334,900.
Where this listing falls among 4 homes for sale
Carthage has a population of 754 with a median household income of $42,500 and a homeownership rate of 57.6%. The median home value is $88,900 and the median rent is $906/mo.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023, Fizbo listing data