0%
195 Case Avenue, Andover, OH
Welcome to 195 Case Ave in Andover! This charming 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom home offers 790 square feet of comfortable living space and has been extensively updated throughout. Recent improvements include new windows, furnace, hot water tank, updated plumbing, and a 200-amp electrical service with new wiring. The exterior has also been refreshed with new siding, fresh paint, and a brand-new front porch, adding great curb appeal and a welcoming place to relax. Located just minutes from Pymatuning State Park and Pymatuning Lake, this home offers easy access to boating, fishing, camping, and outdoor recreation. It’s also conveniently close to local schools and the amenities in the village of Andover. With its proximity to the lake and state park, this property could make a great year-round home, weekend getaway, or potential short-term rental opportunity. Affordable, move-in-ready homes in this area don’t come around often—schedule your showing today!

Fizbo Market Record — April 7, 2026 Compared against 13 active listings in Andover, OH, 0 in the state of Ohio, and 182,000+ nationwide, here is where this property stands. This single-family residence at 195 Case Avenue a unique blend of age and charm. The listing notes recent improvements including new windows, furnace, hot water tank, updated plumbing, and a 200-amp electrical service with new wiring. These upgrades have been made to the original 1916 bungalow, which is situated on a 0.51-acre lot with 22,215 square feet of land. Priced at $115,000, this listing ranks as the most affordable option in Andover, priced below all other active listings. In fact, it's priced above only 12% of statewide inventory, indicating a competitive pricing strategy. However, its price is still significantly lower than the city median of $220,000 and state median of $250,000. When comparing specs to price, we see that this listing ranks higher in terms of lot size (15th percentile) and year built (8th percentile), suggesting it offers more home for the money. One notable differentiator is its proximity to Pymatuning State Park and Lake, which could make it an option for buyers seeking a lakefront lifestyle. However, it's worth noting that only 12% of competing listings in Andover include an in-law suite or similar feature, so this listing may not have the same level of amenities as some competitors. With 13 active listings in the city and a median days on market of 37, competition is moderate but manageable. Given its affordable price point and recent upgrades, this property could be an option for buyers seeking a move-in-ready home. The agent should emphasize the property's unique features and location to potential buyers, while also being prepared to address any concerns about the property's age or lack of certain amenities.
Property Type
SingleFamilyResidence
Style
Bungalow
Year Built
1916
Lot Size
0.51 acres
Days on Market
2 days
Full Baths
1
MLS #
1154861402
Listing Type
Residential
Market
YESMLS
District
Pymatuning Valley LS - 407
195 Case Avenue, Andover, OH 44003 — Ashtabula County
Paul J Gall III
RE/MAX Rising

4078 Dawley Road, Ravenna

34424 Euclid Avenue Unit 252, Willoughby

6453 Brandywine Drive, Andover

6677 Morningview Drive, Andover

4594 Center Road, Andover

6738 State Route 7, Andover
143 Hickory Street, Andover
5378 Owen Hill Road, Andover
How this home compares across city, state, and national benchmarks
Listed at $115,000, this 1-bed SingleFamilyResidence in Andover is 2% below the Census median home value of $117,900 for Andover. Ohio's median home value is $150,936, putting this listing 24% below the state benchmark. The U.S. national median home value is $334,900.
Where this listing falls among 14 homes for sale
Andover has a population of 680 with a median household income of $54,821 and a homeownership rate of 62%. The median home value is $117,900 and the median rent is $729/mo.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023, Fizbo listing data