Rentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For RentRentals Sugar City · ID Homes For Rent

Rentals

← Back to Fizbo

Sugar City Rentals

6Rentals

$1,598Avg/Mo

$1,095Low

$2,000High

5Now

425 S 3rd W, #5201, Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 17

$1,195/mo

Available Apr 13

425 S 3rd W

2 bd1 ba955 sqft

Apartment·via Legacyrentalmgmt·N/A

View Listing

1 / 10

$1,795/mo

Available Now

110 W 7th South

3 bd2 ba1,440 sqft

Single Family·via Savoye Apartments·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed

View Listing

467 Huckleberry Ln, Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 18

$1,750/mo

Available Now

467 Huckleberry Ln

3 bd2.5 ba1,630 sqft

Townhouse·via Savoye Apartments·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

425 S 3rd W - #9101, Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 16

$1,095/mo

Available Now

425 S 3rd W - #9101

2 bd1 ba955 sqft

Apartment·via Legacyrentalmgmt·N/A

View Listing

1 / 34

$1,750/mo

Available Now

430 S. 3rd W.

3 bd2.5 ba1,630 sqft

Townhouse·via Legacyrentalmgmt·Cats not allowed, Dogs not allowed

View Listing

No photo

$2,000/mo

Available Now

1181 North 16th E

3 bd2 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Red Barn Management LLC·N/A

View Listing

$1,750

Median Rent

Pet Friendly

$1,515

Avg Deposit

1,322

Avg Sqft

$900–$2,050

Deposit Range

955–1,630

Sqft Range

—

Year Built

—

Avg Year

Avg Rent by Bedroom

2 bd

$1,145(2)

3 bd

$1,824(4)

Property Types

Apartment

233%

Single Family

233%

Townhouse

233%

Lease Terms

Rent: $1,195 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $1,095 | Available 4/13/26

117%

Rent: $1,095 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $900 | Available 3/30/26

117%

Rent: $1,795 | Application Fee: $45 | Security Deposit: $1,795 | Available Now

117%

Rent: $1,750 | Application Fee: $45 | Security Deposit: $1,750 | Available Now

117%

Not specified

117%

Rent: $1,750 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $1,500 | Available Now

117%

Property Managers

Legacyrentalmgmt

350%

Savoye Apartments

233%

Red Barn Management LLC

117%

Availability

Available Now

583%

Within 30 Days

117%

30+ Days Out

00%

Popular Features

Central Air Conditioning2In Unit Washer & Dryer2

Rental Market Analysis — Sugar City, ID

Fizbo has collected 6 rental listings in Sugar City, ID. Among these, monthly rents range from $1,095 to $2,000, with an average of $1,598/mo and a median of $1,750/mo. 5 units are available for immediate move-in, and 1 more becomes available within the next 30 days.

These properties range from 2 to 3 bedrooms and 1 to 2.5 bathrooms, averaging 2.7 beds / 1.8 baths. Living space averages 1,322 sqft (range: 955–1,630 sqft). Rent scales with size: 2-bedroom units average $1,145/mo (2 listings), 3-bedroom units average $1,824/mo (4 listings).

These listings are primarily composed of Apartments (33%), Single Familys (33%) and Townhouses (33%). Security deposits average $1,515, ranging from $900 to $2,050.

3 of 6 listings (50%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 3 property management companies, led by Legacyrentalmgmt (3 listings). The most common lease arrangement is Rent: $1,195 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $1,095 | Available 4/13/26, covering 17% of listings.